Two businessmen shaking hands in street

Should you comment before sending a LinkedIn connection request?

A stranger with a headline gets judged harshly. Leave two or three good comments first, and your request lands from someone they already half know. Here is the 20-minute routine.

Should you comment before sending a LinkedIn connection request? Yes, commenting first is the best warm-up LinkedIn gives you, as long as each comment adds something. Two or three thoughtful comments mean your name is familiar when the request lands, so they accept someone they already half know.

Jump to a question

Commenting before connecting is the oldest networking move there is, moved online. Commenting first is what you would do at a “braai” (barbecue): you join the circle, add something to the story, and only then do you introduce yourself.

Nobody walks up to a group at a “braai”, hands out a business card and asks to be friends. On LinkedIn people do it all day, and then wonder why their connection requests are not being accepted.

Why does commenting feel so uncomfortable?

Commenting feels uncomfortable because it means holding an opinion in public, in front of the person you want to meet. The worries I hear are always the same. A comment might read as self-promotion. The feed looks like a circus. And there is no time in the week. All three are reasonable, and all three have a fix.

The feed is noisy. The Noise Machine has filled the comment sections with "Great insights, thanks for sharing!" from AI comment tools, engagement pods (groups who agree to like and comment on each other's posts) trading likes, and people who comment only to slip a pitch into the replies. If that is what commenting looks like, no wonder serious people stay out of it.

But staying out has a cost. When your request lands, the other person has no idea who you are. You are a stranger with a headline. And strangers get judged harshly.

Stylish banker with documents looking away while talking on smartphone in blurred office

So should you comment before you connect?

Yes, with one condition: the comment has to add something to the conversation. A good one does three jobs. It shows the author you read the post. It shows everyone else in the thread how you think. And it puts your name in front of the person you want to meet two or three times before you ask for anything.

Do it right and something useful happens. They often visit your profile within the day. They start to recognise your name. When the request finally arrives, it feels like the next step in a conversation that has already started, rather than an ambush from a stranger.

I hold one rule above all the others. If you have to choose between posting and commenting, comment. Comments drive more visibility than posts, and they are far easier to fit into a busy week. If your own posts are struggling to get seen, why your posts get almost no impressions explains the connection.

What does a good comment look like?

A good comment is 15 words or more and adds a view, an example or a question, with no pitch. The test I give every client is simple. Did a third person join the conversation? If someone else replied, agreed, disagreed or asked you a question, it worked. If it just sat there, it was decoration.

Remember who you are really writing for. The author has seen a hundred comments today. The people reading the comments are the ones who decide whether to click on your name.

  • Fifteen words or more. Anything shorter is a reaction wearing a comment's clothes.
  • A view, an example or a question. Agree and add a case from your own work. Disagree politely and say why. Ask the author something their post made you wonder.
  • No pitch, no link, no "DM me". The moment you sell in the comments, you are back in the Noise Machine.
  • Be specific. "This matches what I saw with a manufacturing client last year, the bottleneck was the handover, not the hiring" beats "So true!" every time.

If your last 20 comments were congratulations, we need to talk about literally anything else.

How do you do this yourself, step by step?

Pick 20 people who post, comment on their posts once a day, send the request with no note after two or three comments, and thank them with one question when they accept. That is the whole routine. It fits into 20 minutes a day, and you can start it on Monday. Here it is, step by step.

  1. Pick your 20. From your target list, choose the 20 people you most want to talk to who have posted in the last 30 days. If they never post, commenting will not reach them, so they go on the plain request list instead.
  2. Turn on notifications for their posts. Ring the bell on their profiles so you see their posts early, while the comment section is still small.
  3. Comment once a day. Read the whole post. Write 15 words or more that add something. Then come back later and reply to anyone who answered you.
  4. Send the request after two or three comments. Send it without a note. If I put a message, you put me in a box. If I put no message, you're curious. The full reasoning is in whether you should add a note to a connection request.
  5. Thank them when they accept. One short thank-you and one easy question about why they said yes. No pitch.
  6. Keep score on Friday. Keep the 20 names in a simple list with three columns: comments left, request sent, accepted. Anyone who has not posted for a month comes off and the next name goes on.

Set aside an hour a day for commenting if you can. If you cannot, 20 minutes on your 20 people is still worth more than an hour posting into the void.

Smiling portrait of an attractive florist business woman owner at a flower shop market working and making a new

How many times should you comment before sending a LinkedIn connection request?

Two or three times, spread over a week or two, is enough. One set of comments can be missed. Five can start to look like you're circling. Two or three thoughtful replies on different posts mean your name is familiar by the time the connection request arrives, without anyone wondering why you keep turning up.

Spacing matters as much as the number. Three comments on one post in an afternoon reads as keen to the point of odd. Three across ten days, on three different posts, reads as someone who follows their work. If they reply to you in the thread, that counts double. Send the LinkedIn connection request that day or the next, while the exchange is fresh.

What if they never reply to your comments before the connection request?

Send the connection request anyway. Plenty of busy owners read every reply on their posts and answer none of them. Silence in the thread isn't a no. Your name has still been in front of them two or three times, and that's the job the commenting was there to do.

What you shouldn't do is keep going indefinitely, waiting for a sign. After three good comments, send it without a note and let the profile do the rest. If they don't accept within a fortnight, leave it. Keep reading their posts if they're useful to you, and try again in a few months if something gives you a genuine reason.

Should you comment on their posts after they accept your LinkedIn connection request?

Yes. Accepting is the start of the relationship on LinkedIn, not the end of the warm-up. Keep replying to their posts now and then, with the same rule: add a view, an example or a question. It keeps your name in front of them while the private conversation finds its feet.

Just don't let the two get tangled. The public replies stay public and useful to everyone reading. Anything about your work, your offer or a call belongs in the private messages, and only once they've shown they want to talk. Mixing the two is how a good reply in the thread turns into a pitch with an audience.

Does this work at 100 or 200 requests a week?

Not on its own, and anyone who tells you otherwise has never tried it. You cannot leave three thoughtful comments for 200 new people every week and still run a business. So split the work. Comment on the handful of people who would change your year, and send everyone else on your list a plain, hand-sent request with no note.

The wider list is people who fit your buyer and have been active in the last month. Across 40,525 requests sent by hand on client accounts between April and July 2026, 31.4% were accepted, and every one of those requests went out blank, with no note. Those were accounts running at full speed with a tested list. The warm-up is a bonus on top of a good list, never a replacement for one.

What does it look like when our team does it?

Our operators send your requests by hand through your own Sales Navigator, at a human pace, to a list you have approved. Every acceptance gets a thank-you with one genuine question. That frees your own time for the commenting that only you can do, in your own voice, on the posts of the people you most want to meet.

Sales Navigator is LinkedIn's paid search tool for finding buyers, and you keep the account in your own name. We never use AI comment tools or pods, on your account or ours. If you also want help showing up on the feed, Content includes daily engagement alongside 12 posts and a newsletter a month. If you are comparing agencies, the best LinkedIn outreach services for founders sets out what to ask each of them, us included.

Who is this not for?

Commenting first is not for you if your buyers are not on LinkedIn and never post, because your comments will never reach them. If you are not prepared to have an opinion in public, it will feel like hard work for little return. And if your referrals are still pouring in, you don't need us at all.

If your buyers live somewhere else, spend the hour there. For everyone else, the rest of the method, from the first request to the first real conversation, is in my piece on warming people up without cold DMs.

So yes, warm people up before you ask. Leave a few comments that add something, then send the request without a note. Commenting before connecting turns you from a stranger into a familiar name, and familiar names get accepted.

Useful? Share it with someone whose referrals have gone quiet: share on LinkedIn.

Questions owners ask before they start

Is my account safe?

A real person sends every request from your own Sales Navigator, at a human pace. Nothing goes out that you haven't approved, and we never sell in your name.

How we protect your account

Can't I just do this myself?

You can, and this article shows you how. It takes two or three hours every single week, and it only works if you never skip a week. We do the weekly part, so you only take the conversations.

Will you sell for me?

No. We start the conversations and hand them to you warm. You do the selling, in your own words.

Will it pay for itself?

One new client usually covers a year of Bronze. And there's no contract, so every month has to earn the next.

See the five packages

Do it yourself, or have it done for you

Do it yourself

  • Pick the 20 people on your list you most want to talk to who have posted in the last 30 days.
  • Leave one comment a day on their posts, 15 words or more, with a view, an example or a question.
  • Reply to anyone who answers your comment, the same day.
  • After two or three comments, send the request with no note, then thank them with one question when they accept.

Or have us do it

Our operators send the wider list of requests by hand, so your own commenting time goes on the 20 people who matter most. On Content, daily engagement is part of the service.

Want to see more from Kenneth on LinkedIn?

Why Nobody Replies to Your LinkedIn Messages
He had a 40-50% connection rate but zero conversations. One simple message change flipped everything

What clients say on Kenneth's LinkedIn profile

“Since then, we’ve been seeing 7 to 10 warm conversations a month from people who’ve been following our journey.”

Austin ShrumCo-founder, search visibility. LinkedIn recommendation, July 1, 2025.

“I started working with Kenneth as Linkedin felt like a black hole of hell and I wasn't getting the traction I needed to grow my business”

Nikki FinucanTransformation and systems. LinkedIn recommendation, September 10, 2024.

“I was targeting the highest-level executives at Oracle and was getting at least eight or nine responses out of the 30 new connections that I made immediately.”

Steve LewisLinkedIn coach for tech executives. LinkedIn recommendation, April 17, 2026.

Read all 47 recommendations on LinkedIn

What 100 hand-sent requests produce

  1. 100 connection requests, each sent by hand

  2. 31 accept the connection. 31.4% across 40,525 sent

Client accounts running at full speed, April to July 2026. Benchmarks, not promises: the list and the replies you pick up move the numbers.

Want to know where your own LinkedIn stands? Get your Visibility Score: twenty questions, about three minutes, and a free playbook with the fix for every gap.